Cthulhu Cultists: Would you date a Christian or Atheist?

As a priest of Dagon [Seriosuly, Wi-Fi is awesome. I get service here in Innsmouth!] I would date any woman who likes long swims to Y'ha-nthlei, bear my creepy fish-frog offspring, and that of a few dozen of my good buddies. religion is unimportant, all of them scream "IA! IA! Dagon!" when ya get 'em in the sack.